American Buttercream

American buttercream, also known as crusting buttercream, is a perfectly stiff buttercream that crusts over so that when you touch it, it's no longer sticky. 
↓ Recipe Never Miss A Cake
Total Time: 20 mins
Serves: 12 cups
american buttercream

American buttercream is a sweet buttercream that is very stable and develops a slight crust on the outside

American buttercream is what most people think of when they hear the word “buttercream”. It’s very sweet, creamy and very stable in hot temperatures. 

american buttercream

American buttercream is great for piping flowers, frosting your cakes or cupcakes. This recipe using non-dairy creamer but you can also use milk. The vanilla flavoring can be replaced with other flavored extracts. 

To color American buttercream, I prefer to use Americolor gels because they are very bright and help you achieve vivid color with not a lot of food coloring. 

If your American buttercream is too dry, you can add another Tbsp of creamer to thin it out. 

How to make American Buttercream

  1. Place your butter and shortening in the bowl of your stand mixer with the paddle attachment and cream until smooth. If your butter is not room temperature, you will get lumps of shortening. 
  2. Add in your powdered sugar one cup at a time until incorporated. 
  3. Add in your extracts, salt, and creamer and let mix on low for 10-15 minutes until perfectly smooth and no bubbles are in the buttercream. 

This recipe does call for vegetable shortening because it helps the stability of the buttercream. You can definitely use all butter if you prefer. You can also use dairy-free butter if you need a dairy-free buttercream.

american buttercream on cupcakes

What are the different types of buttercream?

In general, there are three types of buttercream that most people use. 

  • American buttercream (ABC) – made with powdered sugar, butter and liquid. Very sweet, creamy and the most stable in warm temperatures due to the high amount of sugar
  • Swiss-meringue buttercream (SMBC) – made by combining meringue with whipped butter and extracts. This buttercream is not very sweet and very light. Can be very soft. 
  • Italian-meringue buttercream (IMBC) – made by pouring boiled sugar into whipping meringue. This produces the most stable and light buttercream frosting but is a little bit trickier to make. 

Looking for an easy buttercream frosting that is less sweet? Try my easy buttercream recipe. This frosting is light, fluffy, creamy and almost tastes like ice cream. You don’t need to heat treat the eggs because they are already heat treated through pastuerization. This is my favorite buttercream. 

Cake Batter and Frosting Calculator

Select an option below to calculate how much batter or frosting you need. Adjust the servings slider on the recipe card to change the amounts the recipe makes.

Choose a pan type

Choose a cake pan size
(based on 2" tall cake pan)

Choose a cake pan size
(based on 2" tall cake pan)

Choose a cake pan size
(based on 2" tall cake pan)

Cupcake Tin Size

Choose number of pans

Cups of Batter Needed

8 cups

Cups of Frosting Needed

5 cups

Note: measurements are estimated based off the vanilla cake recipe using standard US cake pans and sizes. Measurements used are for 2" tall cake pans only. Your results may vary. Do not overfill cake pans above manufacturer's recommended guidelines.

Did You Make This Recipe?Leave a rating and tell me how it went!
american buttercream

American Buttercream

American buttercream, also known as crusting buttercream, is a perfectly stiff buttercream that crusts over so that when you touch it, it's no longer sticky. 
4.96 from 73 votes
Print Rate Never Miss A Cake
Prep Time: 5 mins
Cook Time: 15 mins
Total Time: 20 mins
Serves: 12 cups
Calories: 1223kcal

Ingredients

Ingredients

  • 16 ounces (454 g) solid high-ratio shortening Crisco is ok if you don't have high-ratio but it won't be as smooth
  • 16 ounces (454 g) unsalted butter Room temperature (8oz is about 2 sticks)
  • 4 teaspoons clear Vanilla Can use other flavoring besides vanilla
  • 64 ounces (1814 g) powdered sugar
  • 2 ounces (57 g) milk or water
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt

Instructions

Instructions

  • Place shortening and butter in a stand-mixer with a paddle attachment and cream together until blended and smooth. Scrape bottom of bowl often.
  • Place some plastic wrap over the mixer to keep some of the powdered sugar from escaping while you mix
  • Add all the sugar one cup at a time on low until incorporated. Add vanilla, salt and milk and mix on low until blended and smooth. Do not turn up the mixer or you will get air bubbles.
  • Let it mix on low for 10 minutes so it's perfectly smooth. 
  • Cover bowl with plastic wrap until you're ready to use it. Store in air-tight container in the fridge or freeze it. Bring to room temperature and mix on low before each use.
  • OPTIONAL: Make two batches separately. After the second batch is done, take some buttercream from the first batch and add it to the bowl mixing on low speed until the paddle is covered. Let mix on low with the paddle attachment for 10 minutes until there are no air pockets and the texture is smooth. (instruction adapted from Swank Cake Design's Crusting Buttercream recipe) 

Nutrition

Serving: 2ounces | Calories: 1223kcal (61%) | Carbohydrates: 152g (51%) | Protein: 1g (2%) | Fat: 69g (106%) | Saturated Fat: 29g (145%) | Cholesterol: 82mg (27%) | Sodium: 108mg (5%) | Potassium: 32mg (1%) | Sugar: 149g (166%) | Vitamin A: 952IU (19%) | Calcium: 17mg (2%) | Iron: 1mg (6%)
Tried this Recipe? Tag me Today!Mention @SugarGeekShow or tag #SugarGeek!

101 comments on “American Buttercream Recipe

  1. 5 stars
    Thanks so much for sharing this wonderful recipe. I made my first wedding cake last weekend and the bride and everyone else gave rave reviews. During my cake testing I used my old recipe and everyone, including me, thought it was too sweet. I’ve been using cream cheese buttercream because of the sweetness of vanilla. Now I can use vanilla buttercream!

  2. can you reduce the butter by 1/2 and the difference to hi ratio amount.

  3. Hi. Thanks for the recipe. But can i use milk instead of creamer?

  4. Hi Liz. So you use All Vegetable Crisco shortening in your recipe? Before the Trans Fat ban, I was using Alpine Hi Ratio Shortening for my buttercream. Worked awesome. Then I ran out and bought Alpine Soy Flex Shortening. The first cake I frosted using this shortening was a total disaster.. it literally was melting off the cake, even with my air conditioner going full blast. Since then I don’t trust it.. I have read on some sites that to make buttercream stable after the Trans Fat ban, use a shortening that is part meat fat and vegetable fat. I did find that type of shortening from Walmart (Great Value brand) and it works okay, but you have to order the shortening online to the store. And they only have 42 ounce cans of it. I am just curious as to how your straight crisco vegetable shortening crusts without any meat fat in it. Now I have the remaining of the 50 lb box of the Alpine Soy Flex Shortening that I don’t know what to do with.. (any ideas??) lol.

    1. Hi Denise, yes I use all vegetable crisco. Frosting crusts because of how much sugar is in the recipe, not the type of fat. You can make a crusting recipe with all crisco or all butter if there is enough powdered sugar in the recipe. Hope that helps

  5. Good evening!
    I would like to make a double velvet cake for my nephew’s birthday. So I would like to know If I can make the whole cake from the previous day without the fear the buttercream to be melt or to lose taste and appearance.
    Thanks in advance

    1. Yes of course, not many people can manage to bake and frost a cake all in the same day. Check out my tutorial on how to make your first cake for more info.

  6. Hi!!! You’re website/YouTube channel.. everything is fantastic! Just looking for some advice! I am making my second wedding cake in 3 weeks! First one went well… all butter American buttercream cake! My next bride is asking for a fondant cake(with ruffles, lots of ruffles). This would be my first all fondant wedding cake.
    What is your favorite buttercream recipe to use on your fondant cakes???
    Can I refrigerate my LMF fondant cake for 24 hours prior to delivery?
    Thank you SO MUCH!

    1. I use my easy buttercream for everything 🙂 Fondant ruffles are time consuming but easy to apply. Make them as thin as possible and start from the top, working your way down to the bottom of the cake. You can definitely refrigerate fondant. A chilled cake is much safer to transport than a warm cake.

  7. Hi ! I have to say I love your website and tutorials ! Love how you share your ideas ! Your super cool! Thank you ! I live in Australia and I have been asked to make a 70th birthday cake, so weather is warming up and I have a 2 hour trip to transfer this cake! I am looking at using this recipe? Not sure if I should experiment as I don’t have a lot of time to play. I am Not sure what to use as the liquid creamer? Please can you help ? I have been trying to search through your questions and answers and thought just best to ask you yourself . Also what is the best way to travel this cake also so I don’t have a melting disaster as I usually do fondant cakes? Please help and thank you again for your amazing site xx

    1. Liquid creamer is just creamer you would put in your coffee. I’m not sure if you have that available in your area. I you can’t find it then just use milk 🙂

  8. Can you use this buttercream and frost the 1/2 sheet cake the same way you do in your video? I know your video uses your Easy Buttercream recipe (aka easy SMBC). Thank you

  9. When would you use this as opposed to a regular non crusting ABC recipe?

    1. It’s really just a preference of the taste that you like. Some people really like the sweeter frostings. Or if you’re in a really hot area, american buttercream is more stable than meringue based buttercreams

  10. Can I use this recipe in hot humid weather? And are my toppers going to stay on it?

  11. What could I use for a non  diary creamer?. I’m going to try and.make your banana cake this weekend. Could i use buttermilk ? Thank you

  12. can you put fondant flowers on buttercream icing

  13. 5 stars
    Hi I Made my cake using your frosting during the Christmas holiday, and the family went Crazzzzy!!!!, told me to only use this frosting with your vanilla cake recipe, now that want me to make another cake, would you please answer a few questions, my sister wants a white cake with a red stenciled design on it, using your frosting and the techniques on crumb coating, then final coat and chilling, how would I prevent the red stenciled design from bleeding? would I frost and stencil and leave at room temperature or frost and stencil and then put back in the fridge and then the next day just take out of fridge and allow to come to room temp. I wanted to at least ice and stencil the day before, it’s her birthday cake. Nervous about the red bleeding, Please Help.

    1. Hey Carol, I haven’t had a lot of experience stenciling dark colors so I can’t make any for sure suggestions but I would say to make sure you’re not using too much food coloring. Start with pink, then add in red and let it mature overnight to let it deepen in color. Make sure your first layer of buttercream has crusted and is chilled before doing your stencil.

  14. Hi. How long ahead of frosting my cake will this last In the fridge ? How long should it last in the fridge ? Thank you !

  15. How many cupcakes would you say this can ice, say, a rosette onto?

    1. There’s really no way for me to know for sure, it would vary depending on the person and I have never thought to count how many rosettes one batch of buttercream makes

  16. Hi liz, how much of this buttercream i will need for a 8″ 3 layers rosettes cake, i,m planning to use hi ratio shortening because i live in florida, but i only have 4 cups of that shortening, can i add regular shortening?
    Thank you

  17. I’m trying to make a two layer 6-inch cake, and this is my first time trying out this recipe. How much do I use of everything?

  18. In your description you mention creamer but your recipe mentions milk and water? I have made Sugar Shacks version of this with all shortening and the hot creamer but I do not wish to make that much buttercream. Can you tell me where you use the creamer? mix etc?

  19. 5 stars
    Wow! Idk why I didn’t make this sooner. I always use Liz’s Easy Buttercream which is nice and smooth and not overly sweet but I’ll be switching to this American Buttercream as my new go to for party cakes! It’s super delicious compared to other American Buttercreams I’ve tried and it’s the sweetness my clients are wanting. I really love this recipe. One batch makes a lot! I actually can’t double it in my 4.5 qt. Kitchen Aid lol. Thank You Liz for another amazing recipe

  20. Hey Liz, What brands are high ratio shortening? Do grocery stores sell it?

  21. Hi Liz,
    Could you please clear something up for me about this recipe?? I’ve always used Chelsweets american buttercream recipe (https://chelsweets.com/2016/11/01/the-best-american-buttercream-recipe/). I thought I’d try yours just for fun, but I’m having big time problems. I did use all butter instead of half shortening, half butter (so 4 sticks), but after weighing out 64 oz of powdered sugar into a bowl (yes, I zeroed out the scale with the empty bowl on it first), I thought, wow! That is a ton of sugar! I decided to try to trust the recipe, but the more sugar I added, but stiffer it got, until I couldn’t add any more in because my kitchenaid mixer was burning up hot and the buttercream was so stiff it was completely clearing the sides of the bowl. I still have probably 3 cups left to add, and there’s no way I can do that. I feel like I have no choice but to scrap the rest of the sugar and just add more liquid until it’s normal consistency. I think your recipe calls for about double the amount of sugar than other buttercream recipes do. Is there any chance you accidentally wrote double the amount of sugar in the recipe that you meant to? I don’t mean to question you (you’re the pro!), but I’ve never had a problem like this before. Thoughts?

    1. You didn’t use enough butter. You said you used four sticks which is only 16 ounces. The recipe calls for 16 ounces of butter and 16 ounces of shortening. If you don’t want to use shortening then you need to replace it with more butter.

  22. 5 stars
    Hi liz i love this recipe. what is the ratio for adding chocolate ganache to my buttercream?

  23. How long can this frosting sit out and still be safe to eat? Thank you!

  24. Hi Liz!.

    Can a chocolate drip be done over this buttercream?. I am doing a semi naked cake & they want a chocolate drip.
    Should I use this American buttercream receipe or your other buttercream receipe?.
    Please advise.
    Thank you!. 🙂

  25. 5 stars
    Is this right??
    I was comparing this to my own recipe just to see what’s out there. TWO ounces of milk to all this?
    Comments seem to suggest what I was thinking. This is going to be so thick, no?
    This is almost identical to mily recipe, but it would have to be more like 20 ounces (maybe 12 depending on type) of milk. 😳 (I use evaporated milk, which I know would yield different results, but such a drastic difference between recipes!). I once eyeballed the sugar and put just slightly too much and THAT was impossible to mix.
    Just commenting to help out, in case I’m missing something!

    1. Nope, not missing anything. I only use 2 oz of milk. The recipe is mostly butter and sugar with just a small amount of liquid

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating